Bad News Travels Fast: Allan Kozinn and The New York Times

Yesterday, Norman Lebrecht leaked that The New York Times has taken Allan Kozinn off the music-criticism beat. The news spread fast, and it did not go over well.

Robert Schwimmer started a petition almost immediately on change.org to reinstate Kozinn, and now has 899 signatories.  Fellow critics chimed in: Alex Ross expressed his disappointmentTim Smith smelled a rat; Tim Page rambled on in the comments section of Lebrecht’s blog post.

As complimentary as people have been of Kozinn, the outcry is really as much about a general dissatisfaction with the Times‘s classical-music coverage as it is about this particular “reassignment.”
The comments section accompanying Lebrecht’s original post is loaded with Times-related animus. Pianist and From the Top host Christopher O’Riley, calling Kozinn a “level headed, agenda-free music critic,” took a clear shot at the Grey Lady: “the (sic) same cannot be said for the posers and pretenders who’ve come and gone (and now appear to be taking up residence) at The Times.”

The person taking up residence is, apparently, Zachary Woolfe. Lebrecht claims that the situation is “rooted entirely in the poison of internal politics” at the Times, and claims that it is a not-so-subtle attempt to install Woolfe as Anthony Tommasini’s heir apparent at the expense of Kozinn. Commenters piled on, criticizing Woolfe’s writing for being petty, overly critical, and just plain mean.

Kozinn’s own statement on Facebook confirming the change was entirely classy, yet telling in what it omitted. While making a point of mentioning fellow Times critic Steve Smith as one of his colleagues whose work he will follow, Kozinn made no mention of Tommasini, Woolfe, or any of the other classical-music writers.

When I was a publicist, Kozinn was always incredibly professional and collegial, and treated me with respect. That good naturedness is reflected in his writing: like Steve Smith, I always get the sense that he genuinely loves music, loves his job, and wants to share that love–free of condescension–with all of us. Give his recent piece on John Cage a read–with hope that Kozinn will do more like this as the Times‘s new culture reporter.

Orchestra Watch: Indianapolis, San Antonio (Update: San Antonio Musicians’ Letter to the Board on Texas Public Radio Blog)

It’s hard to imagine losing 40% of your income in one fell swoop, but that’s what might happen to the Indianapolis Symphony Orchestra musicians, who are negotiating a contract with management. Drew McManus gives an overview here, and argues that the big problem is a lack of administrative leadership. (It’s not that they’re leadership is weak or ineffective: they have no CEO and no VP of Development.) The current contract expires September 3.

The San Antonio Symphony has been working under an extension of its 2007-11 contract, and its expiring today. The musicians asked its board for talks back on August 14; in April, when the musicians last requested talks, management said they weren’t ready.

Things aren’t so great for either Minneapolis-area orchestras, either.

No news in Atlanta, though.

Update (Saturday, September 1)

John Clare of Texas Public Radio in San Antonio let me know that you can find the letter here, as well as an interview with the musicians’ negotiating committee.

Responses to the Detroit Institute of Arts Property Tax. And What’s a Millage, Anyway?

The recently approved “millage” that would provide $23 million a year over the next 10 years to the Detroit Institue of Arts was met with praise by Terry Teachout, who sees the small property tax as a creative and responsible way for an arts organization to raise funds:

To begin with, the DIA showed it was serious about money by slashing every thimbleful of fat out of its budget. It simultaneously showed itself to be responsive to the wishes of its patrons by undertaking an imaginative resinstallation of the museum’s permanent collection that was both user-friendly and artistically responsible. Then, when the DIA asked for public funding, it sweetened the pill with an equally imaginative free-admission plan that targeted not just Detroiters but local suburbanites. 

Not so fast, says Mark Stryker of the Detroit Press.

He points out that the resulting givebacks to the community–free admission for Wayne, Macomb, and Oakland county residents, and extended museum hours for school trips–would not only result in $4 million in lost revenue, but would also grow the overall budget from $25 million to $30 million.

The World Socialist Web Site is against the millage.

Diane Ragsdale gives a good round-up of responses to the Detroit Institute of Arts tax, and raises her own questions here.

What’s a millage? I’ll punt to Wikipedia.

More on Debussy

Debussy’s 150th birthday was Wednesday; now’s as good a time as any to get to know more about him.

Last week, WQXR broadcast a series of programs dedicated to Debussy’s music for the piano, and you can hear them all on its website.

Also on WQXR.org is an interview with Pierre-Laurent Aimard. On his Telegraph blog, Stephen Hough discusses just how different Debussy and Ravel are.

Oxford University Press posted a biographical essay on its blog. Gramophone magazine has its own page devoted to Debussy, complete with a top-ten recordings list.

In October, Eastman School of Music hosts a month-long Debussy festival, and the Rochester Philharmonic performs the composer’s Petite suite and Fantaisie for Piano and Orchestra with Matthias Bamert and pianist Stefan Arnold.

Phyllis Diller Was Quite the Musician

Boy, you think you know a person. Her New York Times obituary notes that throughout the 1970s, Phyllis Diller performed as Dame Illya Dillya with over 100 orchestras. Janelle Gelfand, on the Cincinnati Enquirer website, recounted a 1972 appearance with the Pops and Erich Kunzel that included not just performances of Bach and Beethoven, but also Diller singing “The Ladies Who Lunch.”

In 1969, she played harpsichord with Liberace:

 Here she is playing saxophone on the Muppet Show:

If you can’t read, here’s NPR’s report on her death.

Famous Passings This Week

Phyllis Diller, Gong Show co-host (among other things), died this week.
So did Jerry Nelson, the voice of Count von Count who also had a role in Robocop 2. (Buzzfeed tribute with videos and GIFs here.)

Colony Music, housed in Times Square’s famous Brill building, will close in September, the same month that The Office starts its final season. And hippie-dippy weirdo label New Albion is going out of business too.

Atlanta Symphony Orchestra Contract Deadline Midnight Saturday

According to Adaptistration and the Atlanta Journal-Constitution, the Atlanta Symphony Orchestra has set midnight this Saturday as the deadline for when its musicians must reach agreement with them on a new contract.

The Atlanta Symphony Orchestra Players Association released a statement claiming that the ASO’s negotiator, Don Fox, wrote: “unless an agreement is reached by midnight, August 25th, we have no authority to continue income for Musicians, either pay or benefits, beyond that date.”

The musicians, as reported in the Journal-Constitution, are willing to take an 11% cut in pay (base salary is $88,400) if staff also takes a hit. Orchestra president Stanley Romanstein claims that the administration has already seen its remuneration decrease by 1.7% since 2006, while the musicians have said that staff salaries have increased by 50% over the same period. (I’m not sure what accounts for the hugely divergent numbers.)

The ASO is facing an accumulated debt of $20 million, and has an annual operating budget of about $46 million.

Read about it here, here, and here.

It’s been a tough couple of weeks for the ASO. Back on August 12, it had to fake its way through an Il Divo concert, a humiliating affair, and also has been accused of reverse discrimination (the ASO’s side of the story here).

Better Know a Composer: Claude Debussy

Pointing out the lack of attention paid to Debussy’s 150th birthday (which is today), Anthony Tommasini thinks we take him for granted:

We like to think we know and admire Debussy. Ah, Debussy the great Impressionist! For painting there is Monet. For music, Debussy. “La Mer,” how gorgeous. There are the inventive piano pieces, with their watery textures and evocative titles like “Estampes” and “Images.” And of coures the diaphanous orchestral beauties of “Prelude to the Afternoon of a Faun.” 

Pierre-Laurant Aimard, who has a recording of Debussy’s Preludes coming out in October, thinks we don’t really know him at all–and probably never will:

We don’t always know what it (Debussy’s music) is about …. because things are mixed, they are also not completely said. Things remain hidden.

Case in point for Aimard is Jeux:

Debussy wrote Jeux on commission from the Ballets Russes; audiences didn’t take to Nijinsky’s choreography at its premiere in 1913, and the music even today can be daunting. As Aimard puts it, “we can’t find any more rules in terms of orchestration, of form, of harmony, of music-making.”

There’s a particular moment in the opening of the piece where Debussy repeats a short gesture three times. It’s done with such unexpected suddenness, that at first you think it must be a mistake in the recording (like a record skipping). Hearing it live for the first time, in 1913, must have been completely disorienting.

For Tommasini, Debussy’s innovation was in downplaying the role of pulse, in writing “whole stretches of static music.” With its twists and turns, Jeux shows that what’s really special about Debussy is not that his music stops time, but that it moves us through it in so many novel, mind-blowing ways.